First StitchFix Box!

In case you haven’t heard, there’s all these “subscription box” programs floating around – BirchBox, Glossybox, Sock Panda, Barkbox, and more (more here: I finally found one I wanted to try – StitchFix!

Premise of a Subscription Box

For those that don’t know, most of these programs involve one of two main ideas. You normally either pay a base fee and each month you get a wonderful box of goodies each month or pay just a little bit upfront and then pay more if you keep the items in the box. Whatever the subscription method, it’s mostly just a fun way to get a regular package in the mail to get stuff you might like – no fuss, no muss, no shopping – just fun.


SFWith the StitchFix subscription, you pay $20 up front as the stylist fee – not bad for a personal shopper! If you keep any of the five items you’re shipped, the $20 fee is applied to the cost and you pay the rest. If you keep all five items, you get an additional 25% off the full cost. If you don’t like any of them, you send it back in their pre-labeled bag and you’re only out the $20 stylist fee.  (read their site for the best explanation)

To start with, you fill out a “Style Profile” to define your style, your sizes and your budget. I was pretty explicit on what I did or didn’t like and my size. This included my bust size (you’ll see why this is important in a moment…) There’s also a place to share a Pinterest board if you have one…which I do. It’s here:


Part of my Style Profile

 My First Box

I signed up in January and the first day I could select for delivery was Valentine’s Day. Wonderful – a nice surprise and maybe I’d receive something sexy to wear out to dinner with my husband. Here’s what I received:

Nessa Love Birds on Branch Necklace from Bay to Baubles

This item was just “ok”. I like classic, simple jewelry and this fit that request. But I’m just not big on birds and in the 5 minutes I had it on it flipped upside down 10 times. Cute for the right person but a NO for me. And at $32 I wasn’t really upset at turning it down.


Jonni Lace Hem Detail Dress from Peppermint

I opened the box and this was the first item I saw. To be completely fair to the review, I LOVE the color – absolutely gorgeous. And I already knew it was a dress from the StitchFix website; I saw my checkout page before I got the box. And I thought it would be a wonderful Valentine’s dress…until I pulled it out. Look at the card below:


I was fairly certain my college-age daughter wouldn’t even wear this and it definitely wouldn’t look good on this 40-year-old body. And I was right. WOW, was I right! It squashed my not-so-small chest, accentuated my not-so-small mid-section and barely covered my cute (but not-so-small) booty. And where it didn’t cling it hung. This is a dress?!

Dress Dress - Side

And to complete my embarrassment and frustration, I almost couldn’t get this silly thing back off! I honestly thought I would have to cut the seam at the side to remove it. My best friend got a giggle out of that fact but I thought I’d be paying for a ruined dress. Thankfully I finally extricated myself from this crazy piece of fabric and it quickly got thrown in the return bag, no second thoughts. Not only a “No” but a …well, you get the idea.

Harper 3/2 Sleeve Jacket from 41Hawthorn

Jacket Card

I love this jacket…had I been shopping for my grandmother. We went from barely teen-worthy to old-lady worthy. Sigh. To be fair, I did try it on and it’s not completely unfortunate on me. It would potentially be good for the office if I was in a more business-attire required office. However, it only works if I want to leave it completely open.

Jacket - Open

Below is the closed version. Again, squished breasts and big gaping holes between the buttons. Definitely not worth the $58 price tag for me. So…another no.

 Sweater - Closed Sweater-TIGHT

Chloe Chevron Striped Maxi Skirt from Lily


Now we’re talking. I love maxi skirts. I’m already a decent height (5’7″) but maxis make me look even taller…and skinnier! I liked the chevron print too. It fit well and was actually a tad too long – an easy fix if I kept it.


You’d think this would be a YES, right? Unfortunately, the $88 price tag was a bit much for this type of skirt. Especially when I already own several maxis I LOVE that cost less combined than this one – and they fit better.

My skirts

So, back in the bag this went as well.

Aleah Heathered V-Neck Dolman Top from 41Hawthorn


Hands down, this was instantly my favorite item in the box. A beautiful heather green, a longer length, dolman sleeves and so very soft. It didn’t look too bad on me either:


I didn’t really like the complete lack of form to it however. So, I threw on a regular black belt and it felt a little more “me”.


Then I tried to style it similar to one of the suggested looks, with black leggings, leopard-print shoes and a bit of attitude. Not bad for a night out (maybe) but not a great look for me.

Shirt Dressy

I was going to say yes to this…but the price tag stopped me. At $48, it just wasn’t worth it. I know now that it looks okay on me without shopping and I can now find it less expensively if I really want it in the future. So, this went back as well.


All-in-all I was fairly disappointed in my first box. I sent it back with honest feedback and also adjusted my personal style form to better match my style (not many changes but a couple). I reiterated that I DO have a style board on Pinterest. It’s filled with looks I like and many of them are tighter fitting tops with cardigans, belted looks & dresses flattering to my size and age. Hopefully the stylist will take a closer look this time and match better. Yes, I’m trying a second time. But if not closer this time, I’m done.

Another Service

In doing a little research on this topic I did come across another subscription box I think I want to try. It’s called The Fantasy Box. I won’t say anything else on that box…go check it out yourself. 😉

XO – T.

PS – Sorry for the photo quality. I really need a new phone! Hopefully future reviews will have better photo quality!

About T.A. Babcock

Writer, artist, mom, special project manager, MS Office Goddess, beautiful dreamer, randomly eccentric lady. (Not necessarily in that order...)

Posted on February 26, 2014, in Reviews and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink. Leave a comment.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: